This recipe has always been in my personal recipe binder as “Mom’s Famous Chicken Sandwich.” I don’t remember what age I was when she started making them, but what I do know is that these sandwiches are divine.
The seasoning for the chicken sandwich
First of all, the seasoning on the chicken is perfect. I love anything with cumin, and the addition of cayenne and salt keeps it interesting without being complicated. The spices have become my go-to when cooking chicken to go on other sandwiches or salad.
The bread for the sandwich
I don’t know why I never think of onion rolls except when I make these chicken sandwiches. I don’t really like bread all that much (I know… I’m weird), but as far as grocery store bread goes, onion rolls are where it’s at.
The sauce
But this sauce…. oh, this sauce. Creamy yogurt, mixed with just enough mayo to not make it entirely guilt-free, spicy, crunchy jalapenos, and tangy cilantro and lime juice. It’s so delicious. I always make way too much for the chicken sandwiches and save the extra to use as veggie dip, salad dressing, etc… Seriously addictive.
Sides for the chicken sandwich
You could stick with something traditional like Homemade Fries and these have a fun Creole Aioli. Or, how about a side that’s cool and light like Watermelon Salad? My mouth waters just thinking about it.
If it’s cooler weather, I think a soup with a big flavor punch would be awesome with one of these sandwiches. Roasted Poblano and Corn Chowder sounds perfect, or you can just search “soups” at the top right. We have lots to choose from.
THIS RECIPE MADE OUR “BEST OF THE YEAR” LIST. THE OTHERS CAN BE FOUND HERE.
Spicy Chicken Sandwich with Jalapeno-Cilantro Yogurt Sauce
Ingredients
Instructions
- Combine salt, cayenne, and cumin. Sprinkle evenly on chicken. Heat oil over medium heat. Cook chicken until golden brown (about 7 – 8 minutes on each side).
- While chicken is cooking, combine yogurt, mayo, salt, lime juice, garlic, jalapenos, and cilantro. Combine well and spread on toasted buns.
- Add chicken, a handful of baby spinach, and enjoy! (Yield 4 sandwiches)
Tools we use for making these chicken sandwiches and think you’ll love:
- Our favorite for squeezing citrus (in this case for the freshly squeezed lime juice)
- Everyone in our family now has these herb scissors and swears by them.
- Cast iron skillet. If you don’t have one you really need to get on board.
If you make this or any of our recipes we’d love for you to leave us a comment and star rating. If you’re into sharing your creations, snap a photo and tag us when you post it to Facebook or Instagram.
Like this recipe? You’ll love these too…
Filet Mignon with Bourbon Peppercorn Sauce 
Grits with Corn and Jalapenos 
Cheesy Poblano Pepper Soup 
Aged Gouda Potato Gratin 
Catfish with Creamy Lemon Thyme Sauce 
Crustless Tomato Pie
Carol says
I have all the ingredients and plan to make your chicken sandwich tomorrow – it looks delicious! We have shared many meals, but this I have never tasted.
Carol says
This was great! Savory deliciousness! A “keeper”.
Suzy says
I am loving how you took this to the next level with the yogurt sauce and the jalapenos! So tasty!
Pam says
It is pretty tasty, for sure! Thank you, Suzy.
kim says
Love this recipe! It was so easy and super tasty! I’ll definitely be making again!
Pam says
Yay! Thank you, Kim!
Pamela says
This chicken sandwich looks delicious! Especially love that cilantro sauce!
Pam says
Thanks. Us, too:
Cathleen @ A Taste of Madness says
This sandwich sounds amazing. And the sauce?? I am DROOLING!! Will definitely give this a go!
Pam says
Awww…. thanks so much Cathleen. Hope you love it like we do.
Tisha says
I am living for the sauce! I am such a spicy food lover this sauce is perfect for a chicken sandwich.
Pam says
That’s awesome! The chicken itself has a little kick too, so it should be right up your alley.