Rich, creamy peanut butter pie is a favorite in our house and we know it will be in yours! With peanut butter, cream cheese, cool whip and an Oreo crust, how could it be anything but delicious?
If you’ve ever had peanut butter pie before, it was probably pretty similar to this one. It seems they all have basically the same ingredients- peanut butter, cream cheese, whipped topping, and powdered sugar. There are variations in the amounts, though, and we think we’ve found the perfect proportions.
Not to mention that crust… you can make the crust any way you want, but crushed Oreo’s? Winner!
Are you getting our weekly newsletters? That’s the easiest way to make sure you don’t miss any recipes, and you can sign up right here. We promise to treat you like family.
Now when I tell you this peanut butter pie disappeared fast, I’m vastly understating the situation. At least one sweets-lover in my house asked, “did you take picture of this yet?” only to find most of the pie already eaten by other sweets-lovers in the house!
Another dessert eater called from the road to demand a piece was saved for him… I’m sorry to report that he’ll have to wait until the next time I make it if he ever wants his slice.
I can’t quite decide if peanut butter pie is a summer dish because of the cold creaminess of it all, or a fall dish since the Reese’s on top make me think of Halloween.
I do know that falls in the South can be almost as hot as the summers, though, so I’m always happy to spend minimal time with the oven on in either season. You do have to turn it on for just a few minutes to set the crust for the peanut butter pie, but after that this is a refrigerator only recipe!
This peanut butter pie really doesn’t even need a topping, but we used fresh whipped cream and miniature Reese’s cups to dress it up. We’ve also seen the whipped cream spread out over the top and sprinkled with crushed candy or chocolate shavings, or drizzled with chocolate or caramel syrup and it always looks divine.
If you make this or any of our recipes we’d love for you to snap a photo and tag us when you post it to Facebook or Instagram.
Are you getting our weekly newsletters? That’s the easiest way to make sure you don’t miss any recipes, and you can sign up right here. We promise to treat you like family.
Peanut Butter Pie with Oreo Crust
Ingredients
- 25 Oreos or other chocolate sandwich cookie
- 5 T unsalted butter melted
- 1 cup creamy peanut butter not all-natural
- 8 oz cream cheese softened
- 1 cup powdered sugar
- 8 oz whipped topping
Instructions
- Preheat oven to 350.
- Put cookies in a food processor and blend until crumbled.
- Combine cookie crumbs with melted butter and press into a 9-inch pie pan. Put in oven for 5-7 minutes or until crust is set.
- Put peanut butter and cream cheese in a medium sized bowl. Using a hand mixer, blend until combined. Add powdered sugar and blend until it is incorporated. Add whipped topping and combine again.
- Scoop peanut butter mixture into crust and smooth out the top. Put in refrigerator to chill for a few hours. Top and serve!*Top get really clean slices, transfer to the freezer for 30 minutes before serving*
Looking for more sweet treats like peanut butter pie?
Grilled Peaches 
Foolproof Brownies 
Strawberry Shortcake Mini’s 
Mini Carrot Cake Cupcakes 
Apple Pecan Cheesecake 
Coconut Pie 
Classic Pecan Pie 
Apple Cider Coffee Cake 
Brown Butter Pecan Brittle Ice Cream
More recipe sources we recommend:
Meal Plan Monday
Weekend Potluck
This pie is totally irresistible! A huge hit at my house!
That’s great to hear. Thanks, Toni!
Oh my! All my favorites in one decadent pie. And thank goodness I have gluten free oreos so even I can eat it! And in south west Florida, fall? What’s that? Thank you for this.
Enjoy! And thanks for filling us in on the gluten free oreos. I had no idea!
Our neighbor used to bring us Peanut Butter Pie every so often… I think I’ll make one for her, using this recipe! Yum!!
I bet she’ll love it!
You had me at peanut butter and oreas… Decadent and a craving killer!
hahaha…. we get it!
This is pretty much my dream dessert! I had all of the ingredients at home and got to work very fast. It’s delicious! Thank you for such a great recipe!
Thank you, Ana! It is made with a lot of pantry staples.
Oh yum!! This will be replacing our store-bought oreo cake for sure!
It’s pretty easy and we think you’ll love it.