Cajun Cream Sauce is full of flavor and easy to make. It’s the perfect topping for fish that has been pan fried, blackened, baked or broiled. Starting with the pan drippings left behind gives it a zesty, seafood foundation.
Cajun Cream Sauce adds a little decadence and a lot of flavor to any fish. Put it over blackened or Cajun seasoned and pan fried fish and you double the punch of flavor. Add it to a more subtly seasoned fish and it soars to new heights of excellence.
What kind of fish is best to top with Cajun Cream Sauce?
Any type of firm, white-fleshed fish will be awesome topped with this tasty sauce. Our personal favorites are snapper, grouper and flounder – not just for flavor, but because they’re easy to handle when cooking.
Catfish would be so good too, and it’s an often misunderstood fish, thought of in many areas only when it’s fried. We wrote a whole post that includes a recipe for Catfish with Lemon Thyme Sauce – a mild, sort of sophisticated twist on sauce for fish.
Are you getting our weekly newsletters? That’s the easiest way to make sure you don’t miss any recipes, and you can sign up right here. We promise to treat you like family.
The foundation for creamy Cajun sauce
The Cajun cream sauce is very similar to the one we made for our Pork Chops. In that case we called it a Cajun Pan Sauce. It really just means that you’ve made your sauce in the same pan the protein was cooked in.
The little bits of flavor left behind are what flavors the sauce. If baking or broiling the fish you’ll want to keep it warm and use the drippings from your baking pan.
So, in the case of the pork chops the sauce was flavored with pan drippings from pork. In the case of this fish the sauce is flavored with pan drippings from the fish.
Another, more down-home name is gravy. Here in the south gravy is the name you’ll hear most often for sauces with their roots in pan drippings. If you ever wanted to know how to make a Basic Gravy we’ve got you covered on that too.
The basic steps for making the sauce
- Start with a firm, white fish seasoned however you like. Our preferred method for cooking is with a light sprinkle of Cajun seasoning and then pan fried in skillet that is not non-stick. We use a little oil with a high smoke point like pecan or canola oil. (more on that here)
- When the fish is done remove it and keep warm.
- If you’ve baked or broiled you’ll scrape the baking pan and add it to a skillet with some white wine. If you pan fried, deglaze the pan with the white wine scraping up the bits from the bottom.
- Slowly stir in the cream which has had seasoned flour whisked into it. Whisk or stir constantly until the sauce is thickened.
- Finish the Cajun Cream Sauce up with a squeeze of fresh lemon.
Cajun Cream Sauce Recipe for Fish
- Deglaze pan the fish has been cooked in with wine. If fish has been baked or broiled, scrape up pan drippings from baking pan and add to skillet with wine. Heat thoroughly.
- Whisk together 1/2 and 1/2, flour and seasonings until smooth.
- Whisk flour mixture into skillet and stir constantly over medium-low to medium heat until thickened.
- Add lemon juice and heat throughly before pouring over fish.
- Salt can be added if needed, but most Cajun and Creole seasonings will have enough salt.
- Blackened fish is excellent with Cajun Cream Sauce, but it will produce strong, salty pan drippings, so seasoning and salt may need adjusting.
- If pan frying the fish use a skillet that is not non-stick
- If fish is pan fried, use that skillet to make the sauce. If the fish is baked or broiled scrape pan drippings from the baking pan and add to the skillet where the sauce will be made.